Years ago I wrote a short story entitled "Spectator Sport" that was published in a small magazine whose name I have long since forgotten. The story was about a young family struggling to make ends meet, who had finally scraped together enough to do some Christmas shopping on Christmas Eve. It was snowing heavily when they stopped in at a small cafe to warm themselves.
Sitting at the counter nursing a cold cup of coffee was an old man, a regular at the cafe. He had a long white beard and wore faded coveralls over a flannel shirt. A baseball cap covered his bald head and it was apparent that he had not washed in several days. He liked to sit at the far end of the counter where he had a clear view of everyone who entered, but close enough that he could eavesdrop on their conversations without having to engage himself.
The cafe was crowded on this night and the little family could only find space at the counter near the old man. The youngest of the children was a small girl of about five years old with big brown eyes that took in everything with a sense of awe and wonder. This was her first real recollection of Christmas and she was fascinated by the all the lights, sounds and colors of the season.
She stared in wonder at the old man seated next to them and finally he smiled back at her. In youthful innocence, she turned to her mother and asked, "Is that Santa Clause's brother? "Well, if it is," she said quietly, "we mustn't disturb him." She gave the old man an apologetic look, but the little girl continued to stare.
The old man seldom interacted with anyone at the cafe. He preferred to live on the edges of other people's lives by listening and watching their interactions with each other. But this time he couldn't resist the temptation to participate in the wonder of the season with a small girl.
"I really am Santa's brother, you know," he said to her conspiratorially. "But this is such a busy time for him, that I seldom get to see him!"
"That must be really lonely for you," the girl answered.
The old man reflected on this for a few moments, "You're only lonely if you allow yourself to be," he said finally. "Santa's family is made up of all the children in the world, so since we're brothers, they are my family too!"
The old man and the little girl chatted together for several moments while the older child and her parents nodded and smiled in encouragement. She wanted to know about his house and his pets and if he knew any of the elves personally. The old man soon warmed to the story and answered her questions with sincerity and authority.
When the family gathered their things to leave, he reached in his pocket and found a shiny half dollar he didn't know he had. He handed the coin to the little girl, "Santa told me you would be stopping by," he said. "And he asked me to give this to you."
The little girl's eyes widened in wonder," He knew I was coming?" she asked taking the coin in her mittened hand. She paused for a moment and then gave the old man a big hug. "I don't have a present for him, but can you give him this hug for me?"
The old man smiled, "Of course! And I'll tell him it comes especially from you."
The little girl waved gaily as she left with her parents. When the old man turned back to the counter, he found that his coffee cup had been filled and there was a warm cinnamon roll next to his cup. He looked up in surprise, but there was no one else around. The cafe had emptied out and the wait staff had retreated to the kitchen to clean up for closing time. The silence in the cafe was broken only by the sound of carols coming from the radio and the soft tinkle of bells.
During this holiday season, let us never forget the magic of Christmas and the wonder of the season!
Best Wishes for a Joyous New Year! -Wanda DeHaven Pyle
Friday, December 13, 2013
Sunday, November 24, 2013
A Thanksgiving Prayer
As Chaplain of the United States Senate in 1947, Peter Marshall had an extraordinary talent for prayer. To him the morning prayer was not just the opening part of the services, but the most precious moments an individual spends with the Lord. When he clasped his hands together, the prayers seemed to flow from the depths of his soul. Dr. Marshall did not write down his prayers, but there were those in his congregation who did. In 1954, his daughter, Catherine Marshall, published the edited prayers in a volume entitled simply, The Prayers of Peter Marshall.
These prayers have sustained and lifted me through difficult times in my life. They have humbled me and reminded me to be more patient, more understanding, and forgiving to one another. In one of his last prayers before his death, he uttered the words, "We are standing on the threshold of time." These words are as true today as they were in 1948.
As the searing tongues of misunderstanding and hatred leap out at us from the far corners of the world, it is far to easy to put our own self-interest and pride before all else and become complacent. Dr. Marshall's great concern was for the plain homespun virtues of honesty, integrity, and goodness of the individual. He saw clearly that we can never achieve nationally what we are unwilling to accede to individually. Over and over he kept calling us back to these basic realities.
As we approach this holiday season, let us look forward with a true sense of gratitude for all the mercy and blessings in our lives. May we get on with the job of creating not only a nation but a world in which all men shall have the right to seek happiness. Let's make this season a time of rededication, when we shall think not of how much we can eat or what gifts we want, but of how thankful we are for what we have.
Friday, November 15, 2013
Seesaw Relationships
In a previous blog ("Dreamers vs. Realists: Magic or Toxic", 5/24/13) I reflected on the
magnetic draw between dreamers and realists. Since completing my novel I have
come to believe that that we are all seeking a balance in our
relationships. We are initially
attracted to those who fill a void in our personalities so that our lives can achieve
equilibrium that we believe will bring us happiness.
Relationships can be likened to a child’s seesaw in that
they are balanced as long as the weight at both ends is equally distributed.
Sometimes one end might be up, sometimes the opposite end might be up, but in
order for it to work at all, there has to be equal weight on each end. In relationships we are magnetized to each
other because we see in the other person something that we need to achieve the
balance. We strive to meet someone’s need and fulfill our own need at the same
time. This is true of friendships, work
situations, and partnerships of all kinds.
In our attempt at balance, we often attract others that are
on the same continuum as we are. If
someone is aggressive, he may attract someone who is meek. In fact the meekness may bring out the
aggression in that person. To achieve
balance, one needs to learn to set boundaries and the other to respect
boundaries. Holding on to resentments only causes them to build until, finally,
the relationship breaks.
In the case of dreamers and realists, the balance is often
achieved when both parties move toward the center or the extreme together.
However, if one party begins to move toward the center and the other does not,
the balance is thrown off and the relationship begins to tilt to one side
resulting in disharmony and disillusionment.
When relationships are in full bloom, there is energy about
it. There is enthusiasm and
communication as each party learns what the relationship has to teach them.
Then sometimes, for no apparent reason, all the energy goes out of the
relationship. There is no enthusiasm for
the job, the people at the job, a particular friend, or partner. This seems to indicate that we may have
learned all we can from that relationship, and it may be time to move on to
another one of life’s lessons.
In Windborne, the three women who are the central
focus of the novel are also seeking this balance in their relationships. When
the relationships end, they must reflect on what really makes them happy and
what doesn’t. They must learn to apply
the lessons they learned from their relationships and pay attention to any red
flags that come up in the future.
They must learn not to be afraid to be alone for a while if
that’s what life has in store. In
spending time alone, they are actually giving themselves the opportunity to get
to know themselves as individuals and to incorporate and integrate the
experiences they have had into their new sense of self. They must learn that
one of the most important relationships they will ever have is the one they
have with themselves.
.
Monday, November 4, 2013
Tuesday, October 29, 2013
Spit and Whittle Benches
"Spit and Whittle" benches were a time-honored forum for old-timers to pass the idle hours of the day and exchange gossip. The topics ranged from the appropriate length of women's hemlines to heated discussions on the politics of the day. The "Spit and Whittle" bench in my hometown was situated in front of the only pool hall and beer joint in town. Local farmers would come into town on Saturday night and play dominoes in the pool hall while their wives shopped and visited with other farm wives. But during the late afternoon hours the bench in front of the pool hall was frequented by old men with time on their hands and an abundance of opinions for anyone who had the time to listen.
Along with the "party line" phone, the "Spit and Whittle" bench was the social media of the day. People did not hesitate to voice their opinions and engage in heated discussions with anyone within earshot. Nothing was ever settled here, but there was a satisfaction in being heard. No judgement was passed down and your opinions and views were often forgotten as soon as your spot on the bench was vacated.
Your spot on the bench was often determined by age and prestige in the community. Newcomers to the bench often stood or leaned against a post to engage in the conversation. If they were lucky enough to get a spot on the bench, they were also the first to give it up if a more senior member of the group arrived.
To ignore the group on the bench was to invite their criticism. It left you ripe for their gossip and labeled you as an outsider. These were the elders of the community and they demanded your respect! If you didn't stop to speak, you must at least nod in acknowledgement of their presence.
Unlike the anonymity provided through today's social media, everyone knew the source of the gossip and it was usually easy to separate the fact from the fiction. As small towns disappear and the old-timers pass away, the bench in front of the pool hall is often empty. It remains as a sad reminder of the times when conversations were open and honest and no one really cared who eavesdropped.
Along with the "party line" phone, the "Spit and Whittle" bench was the social media of the day. People did not hesitate to voice their opinions and engage in heated discussions with anyone within earshot. Nothing was ever settled here, but there was a satisfaction in being heard. No judgement was passed down and your opinions and views were often forgotten as soon as your spot on the bench was vacated.
Your spot on the bench was often determined by age and prestige in the community. Newcomers to the bench often stood or leaned against a post to engage in the conversation. If they were lucky enough to get a spot on the bench, they were also the first to give it up if a more senior member of the group arrived.
To ignore the group on the bench was to invite their criticism. It left you ripe for their gossip and labeled you as an outsider. These were the elders of the community and they demanded your respect! If you didn't stop to speak, you must at least nod in acknowledgement of their presence.
Unlike the anonymity provided through today's social media, everyone knew the source of the gossip and it was usually easy to separate the fact from the fiction. As small towns disappear and the old-timers pass away, the bench in front of the pool hall is often empty. It remains as a sad reminder of the times when conversations were open and honest and no one really cared who eavesdropped.
Friday, October 18, 2013
New Release from Wanda DeHaven Pyle
Author Reveals the Hidden Power of Women in Support of the American Dream
Wanda DeHaven Pyle’s new novel chronicles three
generations who must overcome unexpected obstacles in pursuit of the Dream.
Kansas’ tallgrass
prairie provides a vivid setting for Windborne,
a new novel by Wanda DeHaven Pyle. The
author draws heavily on her childhood experiences growing up in the Flint
Hills to chronicle a story of three generations of women who triumph over
heartache, poverty, and abuse to pursue the dream of a better life. Skillfully
creating compassionate characters with a range of emotions, Windborne is a novel unique in style
and scope. Set against a historical
backdrop of major economic and cultural changes of the past century, it is an
elegantly timeless tale about the nature of love, loss and awakening.
Pioneer women followed
their men into the rolling Flint Hills of Kansas in search of the dream, but
when Virginia Findlay gives up her career as a one-room school teacher in rural
Kansas to marry her sweetheart, she is unaware of the chain of events she sets
in motion for the three generations of women who follow in her footsteps. The
Flint Hills promised bountiful wildlife and fertile valleys, but for Virginia,
Helen and Leah it was an empty promise. Dreams often withered and died from
starvation or the harshness and unpredictability of the climate. Like the pioneer women who came before them,
they are independent and courageous women who set aside their own dreams to
nurture and support others. Eventually, each woman must recognize her hidden
strength and power and find the courage to be true to herself. Through their example, these women guide
each succeeding generation through life and provide a blueprint for making the
important decisions that help them find happiness in life.
“Once I began this work, it
took on a life of its own and I found myself completely captivated by
relationships and the motivations of the characters. I believe there are
lessons to be learned here that will be of great interest to other mothers and
daughters!”- Wanda DeHaven Pyle
Wanda DeHaven Pyle grew up in the Flint
Hills of Kansas and her recollections of life on the tallgrass prairie have
influenced her writing. She retired from the field of education in 2012 with
over thirty-seven years as both a teacher and administrator. Throughout her
career she mentored and inspired women in educational leadership and she
continues to motivate and encourage women to reach their full potential.
Monday, October 7, 2013
Roots and Wings
All across the country the landscape is dotted with abandoned
farmsteads and buildings whose walls are filled with stories of heartache and
happiness. On a recent trip back through
the Kansas Flint Hills to take photographs for the cover of my book, I was once again
transported through time as we captured images of the past. We photographed abandoned hotels and schools
with their roofs open and gaping toward the sky and trees poking through the
windows seeking the world outside. We peeked through the windows of abandoned
schoolhouses to see blackboards still lining the front wall and a pot-bellied
stove still standing guard in the center of the room. It seemed that at any
moment the teacher would appear in the doorway to call the children in from
recess. One could almost hear the
children’s laughter from the swing set that creaked sadly in the Kansas wind. The cattle grazing on the hills and the tall
prairie grass bent low against the wind lent a timeless quality to the
surroundings. There had been wind and cattle
grazing here for centuries.
We were enveloped in a silence so vast that one dared not
speak above a whisper. Only the sound of the wind through the prairie grass and
the gentle lowing of the cattle prevailed. Clusters of trees followed the
creeks and rivers as they meandered through the lowlands. They were protected
from the wind here and the comforting sound of rustling leaves softened the
harshness of the surroundings. But on
the open range a lone tree struggled to stay upright against the constant wind.
Stacked stone fences lined the roadways, laid by hand over a
century ago to mark the boundaries of one’s land against encroachment. Ancient
barbed wire fences strung between stone fence posts built when the railroad age
ended the era of the open range, kept the herds separate. It was as if the ghosts of the past were still
there...watching and protecting what they had devoted their lives to creating.
Most of the early pioneers to the area used whatever
materials were available to them to create their dwellings. The most basic structure was the dugout. It was usually dug into a dirt bank with a sod
roof. Sod houses required little expenditure because they were built from
native grasses and their roots held the dirt together to form building blocks for the house. Very few of these dwellings exist today, because they were
subject to water damage and infestation by vermin and were only used as
temporary housing.
When settlers to Kansas found that the area was destitute of
timber, they turned to a layer of limestone rock close to the surface that they
soon found could be used for fencing as well as building. Besides being durable
and fire resistant, limestone had several other advantages. It could be obtained easily with the proper
tools and techniques and it was uniform in thickness. When freshly quarried, it was soft enough to
shape with simple tools and hardened after being exposed to air.
Since the lowlands were prone to flooding, many schools and
homes were built on the crest of a hill where the endless horizon provided a
clear view of approaching storms and marauders. Although this location provided
little protection from the wind and weather, it provided an unobstructed view
of the Kansas sunset. As the sun sank
below the horizon, it set the entire sky ablaze in shades of bright orange and red
against the golden backdrop of the prairie grass.
Gazing out at the abandoned farmhouses, one feels a sense of melancholy co-mingled with joy. If the building had a voice, it would say, “Don’t mourn for me. I have had a good life. While it’s true that I have seen sadness and withered hopes, I have also watched children grow to adulthood and seen dreams realized. I am here now only as a reminder of the sacrifices made to create this life for you. Embrace me and move on, but don’t forget me. I am the roots; you are the wings."
Gazing out at the abandoned farmhouses, one feels a sense of melancholy co-mingled with joy. If the building had a voice, it would say, “Don’t mourn for me. I have had a good life. While it’s true that I have seen sadness and withered hopes, I have also watched children grow to adulthood and seen dreams realized. I am here now only as a reminder of the sacrifices made to create this life for you. Embrace me and move on, but don’t forget me. I am the roots; you are the wings."
Stone Schoolhouse: Flint Hills National Preserve |
District 22 Schoolhouse, c.1890 |
Stone Farmhouse: Flint Hills National Preserve |
Snokomo Schoolhouse c. 1882 |
Sunday, September 8, 2013
Windborne
A little over a year ago, I started this blog to record my inspirations, insights and reflections as I researched and wrote the novel which has become Windborne. It has been a labor of love dedicated to my family whose lives and stories inspired the work. I am happy to announce that the book is complete with an anticipated release date in time for the holidays. The following is a synopsis of the novel. The book will be available from Amazon in paperback and also as an ebook on Kindle. Watch this site for more information about the release!
Thank you!
Wanda DeHaven Pyle
Thank you!
Wanda DeHaven Pyle
Windborne
Synopsis
Three generations of women overcome heartache, poverty, and
abuse before each woman finally recognizes her hidden strength and power and finds the courage to be true to herself.
When Virginia Findlay gives up her
career as a one-room school teacher in rural Kansas to marry her sweetheart,
she is unaware of the chain of events she sets in motion for the three generations
of women who follow in her footsteps. Virginia leaves behind her home and
family in the Kansas Flint Hills at the turn of the last century to venture out
on her own and attend the Kansas Normal School to become a teacher. She
relishes her new-found independence and is passionate about her belief that education
is the key to a better life for rural America. She begins the journey toward bringing
her vision to reality when she accepts a position teaching in a one-room school
not far from her home in the Flint Hills.
During the course of her short career she not only triumphs over school
bullies, uninformed school board members and natural disasters, she falls in
love.
Bowing to the culture of the times, Virginia gives up her
teaching career to marry Will Caulder, a young cowboy who has big dreams of
owning his own ranch and making a name for himself among the large cattle
ranchers of the day. However, the death of
their first child followed by the devastating effects of the Great Depression
changes everything and Will and Virginia are forced to sell out and struggle
for survival along with millions of others caught in the economic collapse.
Will and Virginia’s family comes of age with the onset of
World War II. Their oldest son is drafted into the Army and their two older
daughters marry servicemen, leaving only Helen, their youngest, still in school. Helen is shy and withdrawn, but Will and
Helen still believe that education is the key to a better life and insist that
she attend college.
Once out from under the shadow of her older siblings, Helen
discovers her own identity and independence.
She passes the war years in a whirlwind of activity with only a vague
understanding of what the war is all about. When the war ends, returning servicemen are
eager to marry and return to a life of normalcy and Helen is caught up in the
frenzy. She is swept off her feet by Jack
DeWitt, a young sailor who promises her the life she has always dreamed of. But
like many returning veterans, he suffers from the stress and depression brought
on by direct combat with the enemy.
Jack’s dream is also to own a large cattle ranch in the Flint
Hills, but having grown up in the city and suffered a childhood filled with emotional
abuse from his alcoholic father, he is ill-prepared for what lies in store. He
is unable to overcome the demons that still haunt him from the war and turns to
alcohol for relief. He comes physically abusive
to Helen and their daughters and one night in a drunken rage, he ends it all
leaving Helen and her daughters to survive on their own.
When Will’s failing health leads to a fatal heart attack,
Virginia is faced with her own unfulfilled hopes and dreams until an
opportunity presents itself that brings her life full circle. In the twilight
of her years she is finally able to recapture the passion and purpose she had
felt all those years ago as the schoolmarm.
After Jack’s death, Helen rediscovers her inner strength and
independence and assumes the role of head of the family, but during the
difficult years, she had relied on her older daughter, Leah, to feed her
emotional needs and provide her with the strength to carry on. Now, Leah is set adrift in the culture of the
1960’s not knowing exactly what her role in life should be. She is torn between her need for the safety
and security of a traditional relationship and her desire for an independent
life and an exciting career. Her choice sends her careening down a path of
emotional destruction until she is forced to stand on her own again and
rediscover the essence of her own identity.
Through their example, these women guide each succeeding generation
through life and provide a blueprint for making the important decisions that
help them find happiness in life.
Thursday, July 18, 2013
Emotional Starvation: a mother's legacy
The other
day I caught a glimpse of myself in a store window and I thought I was looking
at my mother! When did that happen? For several years now I have heard her voice
coming out of my mouth, but I’ve also heard my voice coming from my daughter’s
mouth as she interacts with her own daughters!
What is it about mothers and daughters that causes them to perpetuate
and repeat the patterns and behaviors of the past?
As I
continue my work on the final chapters of my book, I have begun to ask myself,
“What’s the point?” By that I mean what would encourage a reader to say,
“That’s interesting. I’d like to know
more.” What I hope the reader will take away as a result of all my reading,
thinking, research and writing is that the mother-daughter relationship is a
mirror reflection of the culture of the times and the emotional condition women
and girls are living in.
I began
the book with a question, a puzzle that I didn’t understand but wanted to, and
a vague sense of what an answer might look like. Why is it that although the
women in my family were bright and highly educated, they chose partners in life
who were needy and led them into a life of poverty and/or abuse? Why was this
pattern repeated over so many generations? I hoped that out of my early
research there would emerge a solution-- an idea that seemed promising. So I
started writing to see whether I could build a story that would illustrate and
shed light on the puzzle.
One of the strongly held
themes I discovered was that selflessness by the women in my family was treated
as a badge-of-honor that they had learned to wear proudly. Each woman had experienced
a change in their understanding of their roles in life. As each one chose a life partner, they silenced
themselves from being strong, independent women to women who accepted invisibility
and a belief that caring for others and not herself was “a woman’s lot in
life”. And each had passed this sense of invisibility on their
daughters.
As I wrote, I saw in front
of me, as if projected on the wall, a time-line of all the abusive experiences,
events and emotional neglect my grandmother and mother had experienced. I say and even felt how each of them had
suffered life-stripping emotional neglect because no one had asked them what
they needed or felt. I also felt how
each of them had survived this silence and invisibility by learning to believe
that it was a normal state for women.
Our emotional needs are the
bedrock of our ability to know ourselves, take care of ourselves, know what is
right, set boundaries, be authentic and visible in our relationships, and
importantly, protect ourselves from abusive people. Silencing women’s and
girls’ emotional needs is the same as sentencing women and girls to lives of
emotional starvation, invisibility, inequality, and being set-up for abusive
relationships.
I began to see how the emotional neglect and
invisibility had shaped not just their relationship with themselves, but how it
had shaped their relationship with each other. I saw how their shared
experience of emotional deprivation had created an emotional hunger in the
mothers that they then passed on to their daughters. They didn’t know the words
to say or how to feel entitled to claim ownership for their needs or their
right to feel heard, visible, and nurtured. This understanding was as foreign
to these women as a language they did not understand or had even heard of. Not
having anywhere to be emotionally fed, and not knowing how to feed themselves
or that they could ask to be responded to, each mother had passed their
feelings of emotional starvation on to their daughters.
This left their daughters feeling
the same invisibility and emotional neglect that their mothers had felt. It
left the next generation of daughters spending their childhood and adult years
learning about what others needed rather than learning about what they needed.
The mothers had passed on to their daughters their own complete oblivion that
something essential was missing. In their flurry to care for others, the
daughters did not realize that their own emotional needs were missing and that
they didn’t know the language or own the sense of entitlement to claim their
needs. Just like their mothers, they did not recognize how emotionally starved they
were and that they had learned to accept emotional starvation as normal. In
this starved state, they also did not recognize how dangerous it is to be
disconnected from your emotional needs. They did not understand that not
feeling entitled to ourselves leaves women (and men) vulnerable to being and
accepting abusive behavior from others.
Emotional starvation occurs
when our basic need to feel important to others is not met. We all need
emotional support. It helps us to feel
that our life has meaning beyond our jobs and tangible accomplishments. We are
most satisfied when we feel that our hopes, dreams, feelings and desires are
loved and appreciated. Emotional starvation occurs when people allow
circumstances to bind them so tightly into responsibility roles that no time is
available for intimate communication. Focused intimate conversation looks more
like taking a quiet walk while you talk privately and listen intently to each
other away from the hassles and responsibilities of daily life. It takes place
at a slower pace than other forms of communication and it is not outcome
driven. There is no final goal to achieve.
The sole purpose derives from the process itself. For those involved, it is enough to feel
symbolically connected via the sharing of their experiences.
When there is almost no
time spent in intimate communication, a bonded relationship will start to
dysfunction because emotional needs are not being met. Most women like to view themselves as more
autonomous than they really are. As a consequence, they underestimate or even completely
eclipse their own emotional needs from their awareness. It’s as if a person is
starving but has no hunger! When this is happening, most people will turn the
hurt into feelings of resentment and anger. They become hypersensitive and
anger is provoked by even small issues.
In my book this phenomenon
is illustrated in the lives of the three predominant women in the story. They
act as though they do not have emotional needs.
They act stronger than they really feel underneath, and thus, reinforce
the deprivation. Because they do not
expect emotional support, they do not ask for it, consequently, they do not get
it. They also choose significant others who cannot or do not want not give
emotionally. They often choose partners
who are cold, aloof, self-centered, or needy, and therefore likely to continue
to deprive them emotionally.
Because their emotional
needs were never met, the women in my story are not even aware that they are
emotionally deprived. They suffer from depression, loneliness and other
physical symptoms, but never make the connection with the absence of nurturing,
empathy and protection. As a result, they deny that their needs are important
or worthwhile and believe that strong people do not have needs. They consider it a sign of weakness to ask
others to meet their needs and have trouble accepting that there is a “lonely
child” inside them who wants and needs love and connection from others in their
lives. I hope my characters can learn to find the balance between strength and
vulnerability in life. To only have one
side--to only be strong--is not to be fully human and denies a core part of who
they are as people.
Sunday, July 7, 2013
The Importance of Grandparents
“A people without a history is like
wind on the buffalo grass.”
—Sioux Proverb.
The American
Family is in transition! The nuclear family of a mother, father and children no
longer seems adequate to cover the wide diversity of household arrangements we
see today. Over the century, there have been significant changes in the
family’s structure and functions.
Prominent among them has been the extension of family bonds, of
affection and affirmation, of help and support, across several generations
whether these be biological ties or the creation of kin-like
relationships. But as families have
changed, they have not necessarily declined in importance. The increasing prevalence and importance of
multigenerational bonds represents a valuable new resource for families in the
21st century.
Urbanization, increased
individualism and secularism and the emancipation of women have transformed the
family from a social institution based on law and custom to one based on
companionship and love. In the last few decades, with the shift to a
postindustrial domestic economy within a globalized capitalist system and with
the advent of new reproductive technologies, the modern family system has been
replaced by what has been called “the postmodern family”.
Each child born is granted the gift
of life by their parents. This gift is a link to their ancestors who lived
before them. From the beginning of time people have sensed a need to belong. Without this connection to
our ancestors we would have little knowledge of our culture or how we fit in. Through
discovering our roots we become aware of who we are as people. We also come to
understand more about our purpose in life.
Valuable lessons can be
acquired by learning about the ethics of our ancestors. The way an individual
behaves and their ideals are often passed from generation to generation. People
are referred to as being a descendant of so and so. In reality, it does not
matter if our ancestors were heroes or scoundrels. We cannot take credit for
their achievements nor should we be blamed for their faults. It is important to
realize that as individuals we are accountable for our own actions.
In recent years the age
structure of most American families has changed with more family generations
alive but fewer members alive in each generation. Family relationships across
several generations are becoming increasingly important in American
society. They are also increasingly
diverse in structure and functions. As the demographics of the country changes
with the older generation living longer more active lives, the result is longer
years of “shared lives” between generations.
As family dynamics change there is an increasing importance for
grandparents and other extended family members in fulfilling traditional family
functions.
Grandparents have become important
role models in the socialization of their grandchildren. They provide economic
resources to younger generation family members, contribute to
cross-generational solidarity and family continuity over time. They also represent a bedrock of stability for
teenage moms raising infants. In the context of marital instability, the
breakup of nuclear families, and the remarriage of parents, it is clear that
grandparents and step-grandparents are becoming increasingly important family
connections.
An unfortunate stereotype
of the older generation today is of “greedy geezers” who are spending their
children’s inheritance on their own retirement pleasures. In reality, most
grandparents are providing some form of help and assistance to their children
and grandchildren. They have been described as a sort of “Family National
Guard”: Although remaining silent and unobserved for the most part,
grandparents (and great-grandparents) muster up and march out when an emergency
arises regarding younger generation members’ well-being.
Multigenerational bonds are
more important today than ever before, particularly with regard to the network
of family support across generations. These multigenerational relationships are
increasingly diverse in structure and functions within American society. Because the increase in marital instability
and divorce have weakened so many nuclear families, these multigenerational
bonds will not only enhance but in some cases replace some of the nuclear
family functions that have been the focus of so much recent debate.
So let’s hear it for
grandparents! A family is not a set of unconnected individuals doing their own
thing; it’s a cluster of related generations. A loving grandparent has so much
to give to the grandchildren but they can learn from them as well, and this
adds to the general health of a society.
Much research, over the past few years has provided evidence that
grandparents can be vital in providing family stability. With both parents
working, family stress and all the confusions of modern life, grandparents give
children unconditional love, support and valuable life lessons. They are family historians with unique experiences who are contributing to the future by passing on important values and also learning about what matters to younger generations.
In my exploration of changing family dynamics over three generations, I have discovered that while it is also true that
grandparents can rule with an iron rod, undermine the daughters-in-law that
come into the family, interfere between parents and children, prevent or make very
difficult the introduction of change and create factions within the wider
family, grandparents have always had a role in passing on the culture of their society. A study of past generations can shed light on recurring patterns of behavior that if repeated or misunderstood can create further disfunction in the family. This communication and understanding can help to bridge what can be a significant gap between generations and improve the harmony of the family as a whole.
Thursday, June 13, 2013
Real Life as Fiction
One
of the problems of using real-life experiences as a basis of fiction is the
difficulty of divorcing oneself from the events in the story to be able to
focus on a plot that will appeal to a broader audience. Oscar Wilde’s famous
quote that “Life imitates Art far more than Art imitates Life” is the conundrum
facing most writers who attempt to create fiction based on real life events.
Just because “it really happened” doesn’t mean it’s good fiction.
Real
life is messy and complicated and doesn’t follow the rules of fiction. It’s also boring at times, even mundane. In
my attempt to turn three generations of real life into a work of fiction, I
find that knowing the “real” people and events has turned out to be both a blessing
and a hurdle. Sometimes real life can become too unbelievable for good
fiction. A smooth well-crafted story
must have characters that are more exciting, more interesting, and more
disturbing than real life to make them worthy of being read. To make the story
broad enough for readers to relate to I need to give my characters room to roam
and behave in different surroundings and situations. I must take the raw clay
of factual material and shape it into something that is my own creation.
To
expand the scope of my story and create a more substantial framework for the
plot, I must distance myself from the real characters and make them my own. I
must structure the formlessness, confusion, and indecision of everyday life
into the demands of a novel with believable characters and a dramatic plot. The
challenge is to lift the characters, events tragedies and triumphs from the
pages of real life and create a new existence for them.
By looking at the family through the lens of
several generations I hope to present it realistically as part of a larger
social predicament. The historical evidence reveals that families have always
been in flux and often in crisis, and that families have been most successful
wherever they have built meaningful networks beyond their own boundaries. Every
family, even though it is made up of individual members, results in a whole
that is greater than the sum of its parts.
According to Bowen’s theory of family systems, it is the nature of a family that its
members are intensely connected emotionally. Family members so profoundly
affect each other's thoughts, feelings, and actions that it often seems as if
people are living under the same "emotional skin." People solicit
each other's attention, approval, and support and react to each other's needs,
expectations, and distress. The connectedness and reactivity make the
functioning of family members interdependent. A change in one person's
functioning is predictably followed by reciprocal changes in the functioning of
others.
This
emotional interdependence presumably evolved to promote the cohesiveness and cooperation
families require to protect, shelter, and feed their members. Heightened tension,
however, can intensify the processes that promote unity and teamwork within the
family, and this can lead to problems. When family members get anxious, the
anxiety can escalate by spreading infectiously among them. As anxiety goes up,
the emotional connectedness of family members becomes more stressful than
comforting. Eventually, one or more members feel overwhelmed, isolated, or out
of control. The ones who accommodate the most to reduce the tension in others are
often most vulnerable to problems such as depression, alcoholism, affairs, or
physical illness.
Family dynamics are shaped by the social,
economic and political issues of the times as well as by the personalities
involved. Because humans are capable of
change, and family members take part in different experiences, the dynamics
within a family never remain the same. Therefore, I have chosen to focus on the
changing dynamics of the family from a multigenerational perspective as it
copes with the stress of transitions and role changes during times of massive economic
and social changes.
Sounds
ambitious! I just hope I’m up to treating it in an entertaining and
story-appropriate way!
Friday, May 24, 2013
Dreamers vs. Realists: Magic or Toxic?
Many of the most exciting people are also the
most dangerous. Reckless people can be detrimental to our health. To what lows will they go to attain new
heights? Because they've got the emotional range of a roller coaster, when they
go down, they go down hard. Anyone in their path will be dragged along with
them. When they're experiencing one of their highs, they can be nearly
irresistible.
We
are often drawn into relationships that perpetuate a pattern we are familiar
with. We all pick our partners in life in hopes of getting the love we longed
for and may not have gotten from our parents. Unfortunately, in our cleverness,
we often pick partners who are reasonable facsimiles of our parents. Since we
still need love and approval, we continue to try to get it from our partners
just as we tried with our parents.
As
I explore the sometimes toxic relationship between “Schoolmarms and Cowboys” It
seems that what I’m actually looking at is the contrast between dreamers and
realists. The realist and the dreamer are often to be the most unlikely of
friends, polar opposites in fact, often standing in direct opposition from one
another. Dreamers love to indulge in the land of “Imagine if…” They are “big
picture” people with ambitious ideas and high hopes for radical outcomes and
experiences in life. They live with their head in the clouds imagining and
wishing for a better tomorrow. Unfortunately dreams don’t become a reality
based on enthusiasm alone.
When
it comes to relationships, dreamers are romantics. They are inspiring and encouraging
people to be around and their “Land of Oz” mentality makes them contagious
leaders. The difference between dreamers and realists is that dreamers
recognize the change necessary for their desired outcome. Instead of wallowing
in thoughts that reassert the limitations and tribulations that they’re
experiencing they indulge on their dreams and desires and focus all their
energies on what they passionately crave.
The realist, on the other hand, is
much more concerned with the practical details. They pride themselves on having
their feet firmly planted on the floor and their head in the real world. They are practical thinkers and problem
solvers, high achievers and highly productive. The realists have good intentions
to bring constructive ideas and feedback to see forward movement, but they are
often accused of being dream destroyers because of their profound ability to
instantly identify potential obstacles and issues that can bring down a dream
and smash it into a thousand pieces with one word!
Opposites attract, or so the saying
goes, but at first glance this relationship seems doomed. The dreamer is
constantly frustrated because he feels as though the realist is always
negative. The realist is driven crazy by the unrealistic fantasy-like ideas of
the dreamer. However, when the best aspects of these two characters are meshed
together magic happens! When the dreamer can encourage the realist to lift her
head a little higher and dream a little bigger and when the realist can
encourage the dreamer to come back down to earth long enough to put some form
and structure in place, the sky is the limit! The result could be one very dynamic and
successful partnership. The best chance
of seeming a dream fully realized is to get both aspects of these characters on
board. And it is the hope of creating this magic that draws the two
together like moths to a flame.
Unfortunately,
the relationship can just as easily turn toxic. Dreamers are often narcissistic
in that everything centers on their needs and wants. If you have been trained
to put the needs of others above your own, you spend your time in service to
your partner. The relationship begins to alter who you are and you lose control
of your life. You become more invested in the relationship because you are
serving your partner. Yet they grow less vested in the relationship and show
less respect for your efforts. Each day you surrender a part of yourself in order
to keep your toxic partner from jumping on the roller coasters and taking you
on another emotional, toxic ride. You
begin to feel devalued. You get weaker and weaker until you don’t like who you
have become.
So why would anyone get caught up in this terrible
situation in the first place? Why wouldn’t
they get out at the first sign that the relationship has turned toxic? The easiest choice is to continue the relationship
and hope that the other person changes. This is rarely successful, but the one
most socially acceptable to previous generations of men and women caught in
toxic relationships. It’s what perpetuates the myth of “Ozzie and Harriet” that
we all lead lives of perfect harmony. The second is to attempt to minimize the
damage that the relationship is causing by limiting contact, also known as “The
Silent Treatment”, and trust that the other person will get the message. Neither
of these methods of dealing with the situation has ever proven very
successful. The third, and definitely the
most challenging, is to confront the issue and end the relationship in all
forms. This is also the most painful choice if ending the relationship involves
children, uncertain finances and social pressure.
Dreamers and realists will
continue to be attracted to one another as long as there is a chance that we can
create the magic. But if the relationship turns toxic, we must be willing to
cut our losses and move on. Once we know
why we make the choices we do, we can begin to constructively change our way of
thinking about relationships and choose the healthiest option, rather than the most
comfortable one.
Sunday, May 12, 2013
Cleaning Closets
According to Psychology Today, everyone
procrastinates sometimes, but 20 percent of people chronically avoid difficult
tasks and deliberately look for distractions—which, unfortunately, are
increasingly available. Procrastination in large part reflects our perennial
struggle with self-control as well as our inability to accurately predict how
we'll feel tomorrow, or the next day. Procrastinators may say they perform
better under pressure, but more often than not that's their way of justifying
putting things off.
I’ve never considered myself
a procrastinator, but I have suddenly awakened to the fact that I’m actually quite good at it! While I was working, it
was easy to put off things around the house while I focused on meeting the deadlines
at work. Now, in this first year of
retirement, I find that old habits are hard to break. I should, for example, clean out closets and
get rid of unwanted and unnecessary items, but every time I open the closet
door, I can think of a dozen reasons to put it off.
The same demons have
plagued my resolution to exercise more and lose weight. Perhaps the two are related since my closet
is filled with clothing of various sizes waiting for me to get back to a size
where they will fit again. The closet is
filled with the ghosts of the person I used to be and it is a metaphor for my
current battle with procrastination.
After spending last week
doing research for a chapter of my book, I realized that I actually needed to
do a complete rewrite of several chapters to tie up loose ends and present the
time and events with accuracy. Instead of getting right to it while the
information is fresh in my mind, I find myself looking for reasons to put it
off. The book and the research have caused me to open the closet door to my
past and examine skeletons I thought I had buried long ago. I have reflected
deeply on the people and events that led me to the point where I am today and
realized that I wasn’t always fair in my evaluation of the situation. The writing
has forced me to change perspectives on my view of the past and look at things
through the eyes of my characters. In so
doing, I have gained new insight and respect for their motivations, but it is
often a painful revelation…much like looking at a closet full of clothes that I
most likely will never wear again.
The reality is that even
if I were able to fit into my old clothes, I would feel uncomfortable and out
of touch. I’m not that person anymore
and bell bottoms will hopefully never come back in style! I must remember this
as I write. That girl doesn’t exist
anymore, but she is responsible for making me the woman I am today. For that I thank her and forgive her
silliness and misconceptions, but it is time to focus on the person I am today.
It’s time to clean out that closet!
Thursday, April 25, 2013
Life's Speed Bumps
Some
people seem to be more able to shrug negative experiences and interactions
off. They are affected by them, but they
remain intact and grounded in who they are and their sense of worth. Others find themselves deeply affected by
difficult people and situations, and they may find their sense of self and
confidence suffers as a result. I must admit to falling more often into the
second category.
Self-doubt
and fear of making mistakes begins from other people’s expectations of us and
sometimes even their criticism of us when we’ve made mistakes. The information
that was not encouraging and supportive in our learning is the root of our
self-doubt. Many of us, in part because
of the external responses we have received throughout our lives, may feel
self-doubt or insecurity. This type of
negative self-perception that we are not good enough makes it more and more
difficult to feel confident or roll with the punches of everyday life without
allowing them to tear down our sense of self.
I
grew up thinking that family life should follow a “Leave it to Beaver” or
“Ozzie and Harriet” model. Father should work at some ambiguous job that
allowed him to be home most of the time smoking a pipe and reading the
newspaper. He should offer wisdom and sage advice to his children when their
actions required redirection, but never raise his voice or his hand in anger.
Mother should spend her time in the kitchen smiling and looking like she had
just come from a church social, and families should live harmoniously in a
beautiful home with all the modern amenities of the time.
It
seemed to my young mind that everyone in the world lived like this except my
family! My mother worked teaching school from the time I can remember and was
the primary bread-winner for the family. She never had time to bake cookies or
create the fabulous meals that June Cleaver prepared! There was no money for
summer camp, or movies and we seemed to work at the farm all the time without
ever getting ahead. We had none of the modern amenities I saw on television. Most
of the time, we didn’t even have a telephone! Our toilet was a lilac bush at
the side of the house! Running water was provided by a well that often ran dry
during the summer and water had to be trucked in from town.
When
I became a teenager, I longed for the whirlwind of parties and fun that Gidget
experienced, but my life seemed both frightening and dull by comparison. This
was about this time that my father’s alcoholism became public knowledge and I
felt outcast as an undesirable because of it. Our family was focused on
survival rather than fun, and I began to feel as if I didn’t deserve success.
A negative self-image can become a self-fulfilling
prophecy. In other words, self-doubt is
a mindset that sets us up to fail. This type of negative self-perception tends to feed upon itself. We
begin to see the world in terms of experiences that solidify that perception
that we are not good enough. The core
emotion beneath self-doubt is fear. Even the most self-confident among us will
experience doubt from time to time. This dark shadow of insecurity can lead to
hesitation and indecision. If left
unchecked, it can cause us to abandon our course or radically compromise our
expectations. Like termites chewing away at the foundation of a strong
building, doubt can undermine our strongest beliefs. Oftentimes it is the only thing that stands
between where we are and where we want to be.
In
my case, I had always wanted to be a writer, but this endeavor was frowned upon
in my small community and I was afraid of the criticism I would receive. Women should be wives and mothers first, but
if they chose to work there were only three occupations that were considered
suitable for women: teacher, secretary,
or nurse. Since teaching was the closest thing to writing, I chose to major in
English and teach others to become writers!
If we give into the temptation to ignore or deny
self-doubt, it will impose limits on our ability to act. Self-doubt can be a
stealthy problem. The more I studied and read the great works of other writers;
I began to doubt my ability to produce anything of quality and thus, became paralyzed
to act on my ambitions. It seemed that anything I wrote sounded trite and
forced rather than real and natural. So I gave up.
So now, in the autumn of my life, I have decided to
face my fears and meet my feelings of doubt head on. Normally, feelings
override logic, but questioning the validity of feelings brings them within the
reach of reason. For nearly forty years I have forced myself to approach life
from the viewpoint of logic and reason.
In the process, I lost contact with my creative side and yet this is
where my natural inclination lies. Rediscovering my creativity and imagination
has been difficult to say the least!
For most people, self-doubt is just a temporary
condition. Successful people think of it as a speed bump on the road to
success. I believe that if I can take the bump in stride, then I can put the pedal
to the metal, and go for it! Success will be within my grasp!
Saturday, March 23, 2013
Surviving the Wrath of Nature
Surviving a natural disaster has to do
with much more than getting through the environmental, physical, and financial
aspects of the disaster. The increased vulnerability that most people experience
when they have faced extreme danger, death and physical injury, and the loss of
their regular ways of life cannot be ignored. Such feelings of vulnerability
almost always lead to immense levels of stress. And the effects—the emotional
toll--of that stress can vary from person to person.
The
recent heavy winter storms throughout the Midwest remind us of how vulnerable
we humans are in the face of Mother Nature’s fury. Weather extremes are not uncommon in the
Great Plains and yet no matter how well-prepared we think we are, we continue
to be surprised by how helpless we are in the face of nature’s sudden fury.
The
extremes of Kansas weather are often exacerbated by heavy winds that only
increase the storm’s fury. Heavy winter snows accompanied by high winds create
drifts of six feet or more and the temperature can drop suddenly to 30 degrees
below zero with a wind chill making it even colder. The wind and snow are often so fierce that people
can become lost within a few yards of their front doors.
But
winter is not the only time the wind is vicious. In the late nineteenth and early twentieth
century, the settlement of the Great Plains provided the growing nation with
agricultural riches and a bustling farm economy, but the rapid development of
previously arid lands into massive wheat fields had a detrimental effect upon
the land itself. Where buffalo grass had previously provided nutrients and kept
the soil anchored to the ground, the newly plowed wheat fields left the soil
exposed to the elements. In the summer
of 1934, with conditions worsened by a long drought, winds began to whip the
sunbaked soil into thick, dark, low-riding clouds of dust. The dust clouds
assaulted everything, destroying crops, killing livestock and suffocating
farmers and their families.
Of
course the most infamous of the killer winds is the tornado. A tornado appears as a rotating,
funnel-shaped cloud that extends from a thunderstorm to the ground with
whirling winds that can reach 300 miles per hour. Damage paths can be in excess of one mile
wide and 50 miles long. Some tornadoes
are clearly visible, while rain or nearby low-hanging clouds obscure
others. Occasionally, tornadoes develop
so rapidly that little, if any advance warning is possible. The most destructive
tornado in Kansas history smashed through Topeka on June 8, 1966. The storm cut
a swath of ruin though the capital city, destroying hundreds of homes, causing
millions of dollars in damage, and killing 16 residents. It remains one of the costliest tornadoes on
record.
A firestorm
is a conflagration which attains such intensity that it creates and sustains
its own wind system. It is most commonly a natural phenomenon, created during
some of the largest wildfires. Typically the state
experiences most of its wildfires in March and April when ranchers are conducting
controlled burns on the prairie. Drought
conditions and high winds make wild fires especially dangerous. When conditions
green up in the summer and the humidity is higher, it lowers the chances. Kansas Forest Service officials estimated that
more than 41,000 acres were burned across the state in 2012 making it one of
the worst years on record.
But
killer winds are not the only way Mother Nature dispenses her fury. Measured in terms of human suffering,
tremendous losses in property, and extensive disruption of business activities,
the July 1951 flood ranks as the greatest natural catastrophe in the history of
the region. The floods inn Kansas were
caused by above-normal precipitation during May and June that caused some major
flooding and established high streamflows, high ground-water levels and a
minimum capacity for the soil to absorb any additional rainfall.
The
heavy spring rains were followed by the great storm of July 9-13, 1951 that was
centered near the common divide of the Kansas and Neosho River Basins. Precipitation began during the afternoon of
July 9 and continued through the morning of July 10. Following a brief respite, the precipitation began
again the evening of July 10 and continued through July 12. Each day was characterized by excessive rainfall
during the late afternoon and night with little or no rainfall during the early
and mid-afternoon hours. By midnight July
13, unprecedented total amounts of rain had fallen since the beginning of the
storm.
Total
damage from the flood was unparalleled. From the headwaters of the Kansas River
to the mouth of the Missouri River at St. Louis, about 2 million acres were
flooded. 45,000 homes were damaged or destroyed, and 17 major bridges, some of
them weighted with locomotives in an attempt to hold them, were washed away.
Transportation was disrupted as highways and railroads were closed from days to
weeks. One of the more unusual damage
reports came from LeRoy, Kansas where the Neosho River had washed caskets from
graves at the cemetery.
It
is quite normal for people to experience mild stress reactions to natural disasters
like these for several days or weeks afterward. Often, initially, people will
experience shock and denial in the first couple hours or days after the
disaster. When shock occurs, people feel stunned or dazed. Denial means that
they cannot acknowledge that a stressful situation has occurred or that they
cannot experience the full intensity of what has happened. Both shock and
denial are normal protective responses to the trauma of the disaster, which can
be too much to absorb all at once.
After
those initial reactions subside, people’s reactions can vary to a large extent.
Often they may feel intense and unpredictable feelings, though sometimes feelings
of anger and fear may be triggered by specific reminders of the natural disaster.
Some people will have reactions immediately following the event and some will
have delayed reactions. Some will recover quickly and some will have adverse
effects for a long time. Though most people’s reactions will dissipate within a
few weeks, as many as one in three survivors of natural disasters will
experience more severe stress responses. Those responses can last for multiple
weeks, months, or even years.
At
some period, my family has weathered all of these natural disasters and they
have left a lasting effect on each one of us.
It is a testament to the strength of the human spirit that we are able to
pick up the pieces of our shattered lives and do whatever it takes to move on,
rebuild, or start over.
Saturday, March 2, 2013
Grieving the Death of a Child
The death of a child is particularly difficult because it’s
not supposed to happen. It is out of the
natural order of things. Young lives are
full of promise and possibilities and should never be cut short before they have
a chance to be realized. Every parent I
know would gladly exchange his or her own life for the lives of their children.
But sometimes that choice is not ours to make.
When Ken and I got married he had three grown sons and I had
eight year old twins. I don’t know what possessed him to take on a second
family just as his was leaving the nest, but I am forever thankful for the wit
and wisdom he provided in the raising of mine.
I have often said that God brought us together for a reason. It seemed an uncanny coincidence that he
should be grieving the loss of his wife of 22 years just as I was experiencing
a painful divorce.
I was concerned that his boys would not accept their father
entering a new relationship so soon after the death of their mother, but they
welcomed me in and made me feel comfortable.
I made no attempt to “mother” these adult children, but I tried to be
supportive and I loved playing “grandma” to their children.
Greg was the oldest of the boys at age 27. He was married and had a three-year old
daughter. They were struggling as a couple and having financial difficulty. Less
than two years separated Randy from his older brother, Greg and his younger brother,
Lowell. As the middle child, Randy was a gentle, loving young man with a
giving nature. He was enjoying the party life and was living on his own in
Denver when Ken and I were married. Ken’s
youngest son, Lowell enjoyed being the clown of the family. He worked nights at
a local nightclub and dreamed of becoming a top chef.
As parents we are not responsible for the life decisions our
adult children make. We can only celebrate
their successes and stand ready to help pick up the pieces when things go
wrong. Randy’s lifestyle led him to contract HIV/AIDS in 1987 shortly after Ken
and I moved to California to begin our new life together. We could only watch helplessly as his health
declined and his smile disappeared. His
death two years later at the age of 27 was extremely hard on Ken. I could not
begin to imagine the pain of losing a child. But just as he had handled the
death of his wife, he picked up the pieces of his life and moved forward. I’m not sure I could have done the same. From time to time, a memory or special day
will trigger a return of the grieving, but he doesn’t let it consume him.
Last year, after leading a very troubled life, Greg finally
found his peace by committing suicide. I feared that the pain of losing two children
would be impossible to bear, but once again, Ken grieved and moved on. His
greatest remorse was that his children had suffered in their final days on
earth and he had not been there to comfort them. His emotional strength in dealing
with this loss has consistently amazed me.
My grandmother lost a child at the young age of 5 months and
the loss affected her for her entire life. She became paranoid and bitter. She
mistrusted everyone and had difficulty expressing her emotions. To us she
seemed cold and unfeeling. She seldom laughed or caressed us and seemed overly
critical of everything.
I was curious to know whether these two very different
responses to the death of a child were
typical of the different grieving processes experienced by men and women.
Several research articles pointed to the fact
that mothers often have more difficulty overcoming the death of a child than
fathers do. This can be traced partly to
social norms that place the mother in the more nurturing role in the
family. She tends to take on the
responsibility for the care and protection of her young so when something goes
wrong, she takes it as a personal failure and the guilt can be unbearable. Because of the nursing experience, mothers
often bond more quickly to their infant child than fathers. Therefore, losing
an infant when it is most dependent on the nurturing care of the parent may be
particularly difficult for the mother. As today’s fathers take a more active parenting
role, this may be truer in my grandmothers’ case that it is today.
The research also indicates that it is not uncommon for women who
experience the death of a child to experience Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
similar to that experienced by combat veterans. They often suffer from psychological disorders like
paranoia and substance dependency which can last throughout their lives. Treatment
for PTSD has only recently come under scrutiny with the return of combat
veterans from Vietnam. In my grandmother’s time, there was no diagnosis or
treatment for the disorder. Like combat veterans,
grieving parents were simply told to get on with their lives and have more
children. What is misunderstood in this pronouncement
is that one can never replace a child no matter how many children come
afterward. There is always a void and an
empty place at the table. There is
always a life unfulfilled and the dreams of what might have been.
Pretending that the child never existed is not an option for
the grieving parent. There are still
memories to be shared and smiles to be remembered. Just because their lives
were cut short does not mean that they had never lived or that their lives did not
touch others in the short time they were with us. When asked how many children
he has, Ken always answers, “I had three sons.”
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)